Emily has a nice first date with Daniel Grayson. It looks as if it may end with a kiss on the front porch. But Nolan and Jack interrupt any possible make-out session. They are there for the surprise “Welcome to the Hamptons” party Ashley set up with Daniel. By the way, Jack agreed to pal around with Nolan so that he can get his boat back at the end of the summer.

Jack assures Emily that he’s not stalking her, though he can’t say the same for his dog, Sammy. He says it was good to see her again. Emily doesn’t respond, but the unsure look on her face seems to indicate that she reluctantly feels the same way. At the end of the night, Emily finally does have that kiss on the porch with Daniel. As for Jack, he’s devastated when he returns to The Stowaway to find his dad unconscious on the floor. An ambulance is on the way, but it may already be too late.

Flashbacks reveal that Emily had seen her dad with Victoria Grayson in the past. She also overheard David say that he trusted the wrong person. In voiceover, we learn that Emily believes the only person we can truly trust is ourselves. That’s probably why she sits alone at a table with a birthday candle lit atop a cupcake. Emily says, “Happy Birthday, Amanda” as she blows out the candle. Wonder what she wished for.