Sheriff Graham and Emma have had a flirtatious relationship, and he even made her an official Deputy, but when she finds out that he’s been sleeping with Regina in secret, she refuses to speak with him. Trying to win her back, he kisses her, and it triggers his memories of his life as The Huntsman in Fairy Tale Land. He tries to learn more from Mary Margaret, whom he begins to recognize as Snow White from his memories, and then later speaks with Henry, who tells him he must be The Huntsman. Believing Henry, he breaks into Regina’s family crypt with Emma’s help, looking for his heart. They find nothing, but Regina arrives and she and Emma get into a fist-fight. Graham breaks it up, and breaks things off with the Mayor, for good. Once he and Emma have left, Regina reveals a secret chamber within the tomb and pulls the Sheriff/Huntsman’s glowing heart from a box. As she squeezes, the Sheriff collapses as Emma’s feet, dead.