RING! Panic strikes when a phone call comes in the middle of the night. Haley has been arrested! Claire and Phil rush to her rescue. They bring Mitchell along because it's comforting to have a good environmental lawyer around when your daughter gets busted for assaulting a cop. Haley's police beatdown was an accident, but Phil gets peeved when she fails to take any responsibility at all. His outburst inspires Haley to list ALL of her collegiate transgressions to a school disciplinary board. It's an inspiring display of raw honesty. It's also what gets Haley kicked out of school.