It's Valentine’s Day in Port Charles. Tracy renews her pressure on Luke to hunt down the presumed Quartermaine heir so she can take over the company again. Meanwhile Luke has gone to the party at the Haunted Star and is looking out nostalgically from the deck, when he sees someone on the pier.
Connie comes upon Olivia and Steve thinking about the death by water of Heather. Meanwhile Dante surprises Lulu by bringing Sonny to the party. Starr asks Michael to give Sonny the benefit of the doubt when Connie arrives and hears Sonny defend her. Frisco appears at Maxie's to try to get her to give him a chance. She agrees to go out somewhere with him, if only to avoid Spinelli and Ellie celebrating Valentine's Day. Frisco suggests the Haunted Star knowing Felicia will be there.
Lulu encourages Mac to stake his claim. Lulu and Dante deal with Sonny, and happily greet Maxie with "their" baby. Felix tries to cheer up Sabrina, who believes that she gave the dead cop the wrong medicine and killed him. He gets her to go to the party, but everyone she sees there remind her of having killed the cop. Sabrina wants to confess her responsibility to Steve.
Maxie overhears Felix and Sabrina talking about Sabrina's guilt over the dead cop. Felix pulls her into a dance, as Maxie, feeling horrible that she's made Sabrina believe she killed someone, tells Frisco she did something horrible. Lulu finds a wrapped gift behind the bar, thinking it's her surprise from Dante.