In honor of Halloween, James is throwing his annual “Positivity Party” where all his guests must dress in positive costumes. The reason? James hates scary things.

Chloe has a Halloween ritual of her own. She seeks out an annoying party guest, uncovers their deepest fear and spends the next year using that information to ruin his or her life. This year she targets a really good looking guy named Benjamin who is scarred by his mother’s abandonment.

Benjamin was also the director in James's awesome movie, Love Monster.

Chloe purposely reminds him of his mother to torture him, but then she does something completely unexpected. Right when she has him by throat, she panics and admits that she’s been stringing him along. Funny enough, Benjamin reveals that he’s beaten her at her own game. He’s actually been exploiting Chloe’s biggest fear by making her the star in her own chick flick. Now that is truly terrifying.

To see the rest of the recap and more fun episode mementos, click here»
New to ABC.com?