Melissa was paired with Tony Dovolani back in Season 8, when they made it to the semi-finals. She was giving a lot to return to the All-Star season, this time determined to win the Mirror Ball trophy and be the best partner Tony ever had. For their first dance of the season, the pair did a Foxtrot to "Big Spender" by Shirley Bassey.
Carrie Ann: 7
Both Len and Carrie Ann were impressed with Melissa's lines, and Carrie Ann commented, "You have the most exquisite lines. Your extension is fabulous."